ORIGINAL
Environmental characterization of the reproductive season of migratory fish of the Sinú river (Córdoba, Colombia)
Caracterización ambiental de la temporada reproductiva de los peces migradores del río Sinú (Córdoba, Colombia)
Eduardo Kerguelén-Durango,1 M.Sc, Víctor Atencio-García,1* M.Sc.
1Universidad de Córdoba, Facultad de Medicina Veterinaria y Zootecnia, Departamento de Ciencias Acuícolas, Centro de Investigación Piscícola CINPIC, Montería, Colombia.
*Correspondence: vatencio@hotmail.com
Received: October 2014; Accepted: February 2015.
ABSTRACT
Objective. To characterize some abiotic factors during the reproductive season of migratory fish (bocachico Prochilodus magdalenae, dorada Brycon sinuensis, bagre blanco Sorubim cuspicaudus and barbul Pimelodus blochii) in the Sinú River. Materials and methods. From April to October, 2008, in Carrizola (Tierralta, 36.31 km from the Urrá hydroelectric plant) factors such as flow=Qriver, daily flow difference=ΔQriver, velocity=Vriver, temperature=Triver, electrical conductivity=CE, total dissolved solids=STD, turbidity=Turb, cloudiness=Nub, rainfall=Pluv and solar brightness=Bs were measured daily three times/day (07:00 h, 12:00 h, 17:00 h). Also, on the same schedule, ichthyoplankton was collected as an indicator of reproductive activity, assessed by reproductive frequency (Fr=number of days with presence of ichthyoplankton/number of days in the period evaluated X 100) and larval density (Dl=larval/m3). Results. The daily values of Qriver ranged between 278.7 and 838.5 m3/s, ΔQriver between 0.0 and 100.7 m3/s, Vriver between 1.40 and 1.53 m/s, Pluv between 0.0 and 88.2 mm, Triver between 27.0 and 28.7°C, STD between 73.0 and 302.3 mg/L, Turb between 9.7 and 679.7 NTU, CE between 81.0 and 361.7 mS/cm, Bs between 0.0 and 11.2 hours, Nub between 2.0 and 7.3 octaves. The Fr was 30.4%, with April (40.0%) and May (74.2%) as the higher activity reproductive months, while the Dl in the season was 4.9 larvae/m3, with the larvae group other species (2.9 larvae/m3) and bocachico (1.8 larvae/m3) as the most abundant. Conclusions. Most reproductive activity was recorded early in the season (April and May) and parameters such as Qriver, Triver, Vriver, Pluv, STD and Nub may be considered final factors associated with migratory fish reproduction.
Key words: Abiotic factors, ichthyoplankton, fluvial, reproduction (Source: MeSH, DeCS, NLM).
RESUMEN
Objetivos. Caracterizar algunos factores abióticos durante la temporada reproductiva de los peces migratorios (bocachico Prochilodus magdalenae, dorada Brycon sinuensis, bagre blanco Sorubim cuspicaudus y barbul Pimelodus blochii) en el río Sinú. Materiales y métodos. Entre abril y octubre de 2008, en Carrizola (Tierralta, 36.31 km de la Hidroeléctrica Urrá) se midieron diariamente tres veces/día (07:00h, 12:00h, 17:00h) factores como caudal=Qrío, diferencia de caudal=ΔQrío, velocidad=Vrío, temperatura=Trío, conductividad eléctrica=CE, sólidos totales disueltos=STD, turbidez=Turb, nubosidad=Nub, pluviosidad=Pluv y brillo solar=Bs; también, en el mismo horario, se recolectó ictioplancton como indicador de actividad reproductiva, evaluada mediante frecuencia reproductiva (Fr=número de días con presencia de ictioplancton/número de días del período evaluadoX100) y la densidad larval (Dl=larvas/m3). Resultados. Valores diarios de Qrío oscilaron entre 278.7 y 838.5 m3/s, ΔQrío entre 0.0 y 100.7 m3/s, Vrío entre 1.40 y 1.53 m/s, Pluv entre 0.0 y 88.2 mm, Trío entre 27.0 y 28.7°C, STD entre 73.0 y 302.3 mg/L, Turb entre 9.7 y 679.7 NTU, CE entre 81.0 y 361.7 µS/cm, Bs entre 0.0 y 11.2 horas, Nub entre 2.0 y 7.3 octas. La Fr en el período fue de 30.4%, con abril (40.0%) y mayo (74.2%) como los meses de mayor actividad reproductiva; la Dl en el período fue de 4.9 larvas/m3, con el grupo otras especies (2.9 larvas/m3) y bocachico (1.8 larvas/m3) más abundantes. Conclusiones. Mayor actividad reproductiva se registró al inicio de la temporada de lluvias (abril y mayo); con Qrío, Trío, Vrío, Pluv, STD y Nub como factores finales asociados a la reproducción de los peces migradores.
Palabras clave: Factores abióticos, fluvial, ictioplancton, reproducción (Fuente: MeSH, DeCS, NLM).
INTRODUCTION
In fish, reproduction is a process controlled by external and internal factors; the external factors, which are of biotic type (predation, competition, sex ratio, population density, among other) and abiotic (flow, photoperiod, temperature, pH, dissolved oxygen, electrical conductivity, among others) act in different moments and spaces of the reproductive cycle (1).
The abiotic factors can trigger and extend spawning and generate favorable conditions for the development of larva (2). Such conditions are considered environmental factors that stimulate spawning of migratory fish. In rivers that have been intervened by hydroelectric constructions, these incentives could be altered and thus, could affect the reproduction of fish (3).
In tropical atmospheres, the increase in water level, precipitation and electrical conductivity are considered key factors in fish reproduction (4). Jimenez-Segura et al (4) found that in the Magdalena river, the initial and proximate stimuli, which determine the start of the gonad maturity, were high solar illumination and high water temperatures during shallow water periods; while final or last factors, which determined the courtship and mating, were the reduction of solar illumination, as a result of the increase in cloudiness and the reduction of the temperature during high and rising water periods.
In the Sinu river basin there is little information about the abiotic factor characteristics during the reproductive season of migratory fish and which of these can be considered as final factors for reproduction incentives (mating and spawning); therefore, the objective of this study was to characterize some environmental abiotic factors and which are associated to the final stimuli for the reproduction of migratory fish such as the bocachico, dorada, bagre blanco and barbul in the Sinu river.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study location. The Sinu river begins in the town of Ituango, Antioch (Paramillo Massif), crosses the towns of Tierralta, Valencia, Montería, Cereté, San Pelayo, Cotorra, Lorica and San Bernardo del Viento, in the department of Cordoba, and ends at the Caribbean Sea, in the Tinajones delta area. The total length of the river is 437.97 km, from its source until its mouth. At 267 km from its mouth, the Urra (HU) hydroelectric power plant was built, and therefore, the river is regulated by the operation of the hydroelectric plant.
In order to verify the presence of reophilic fish spawning, ichthyoplankton was collected daily between April 15 and October 15, 2008 (184 days), in the upper part of the Sinu river, at 36.3 km (North latitude 8°09’40.8” and West longitude 76°05’44.8”) downstream from the HU (Carrizola, Tierralta, Cordoba). The period evaluated corresponded to the rainy season in the Sinu river basin. The ichthyoplankton was collected three times per day at 7:00, 12:00 and 17:00 hours, at a distance between 5 and 10 m from the right margin of the river, with superficial samples of 1 minute, using a simple conical plankton net with a mouth diameter of 50 cm and a 0.5 mm mesh opening; the samples were fixed in formalin 1% (v/v) neutralized with monobasic and dibasic sodium phosphate and labeled in 50 ml plastic jars. The ichthyoplankton were separated by species (bocachico, liseta, bagre blanco, barbul, and other species) at the Fish Research Center of the University of Cordoba (CINPIC) and their state of development was determined (blastomeration, blastulation, gastrulation, segmentation, pharyngulation). The identification was made based on embryonic and larva characteristics of the fish (5). To the embryos that were not identified, a development stage was determined, and they were counted and registered as other species (other spp.)
Larval density and reproductive frequency. The estimation of the amount of larva collected from each sample was expressed as larval density per day (Dl, larvae/m3) using the following equation:
Where:
Dl = larval Density by sampling (larvae/m3)
n = Number of ichthyoplankton collected by sampling
Vriver = Speed of the river (m3/s)
t = collection Time (60 s)
Ared = Area of the net (m2).
Based on the three Dl samplings, the average larva per day (Dld) was estimated and based on this, the larva density per month (Dlm) was estimated, only considering the days with presence of spawning (icthyoplankton).
The amount of days with reproductive activity of the migratory fish in the Sinu river during the reproductive season was called reproductive frequency (Rf), which was calculated by dividing the number of days with ichthyoplankton presence over the total number of days analyzed x 100. Rf was estimated per month and for the whole evaluated period.
Hydraulic characteristics of the river during the reproductive period. The daily estimation of the river flow was conducted (Qriver), flow difference (ΔQriver) and river velocity (Vriver). The Qriver and the Vrio were estimated three times per day (07: 00; 12:00 and 17:00 hours) based on the reading of the water level of the river, obtained at the IDEAM water level gauging Station in Carrizola (Tierralta, Cordoba); the river flow and an average velocity per day were calculated as well. The ΔQriver was estimated from the river flow differences from one day to the next. The Qriver, Vriver and water level gauging readings were adjusted through eight hydraulic gauging (two times per month during six months) which considered the measure of Vriver and the Qriver at different depths (superficial, 20% and 80% depth) every eight meters in a section of the river at Carrizola (Tierralta) with the aid of flowmeters (A.OTT Kempten, C31-00, Germany) with propeller (2-38798, Germany), flow meter (A.OTT Kemptem, Typ 12,400, Germany) and winch (65645PKS, Germany).
Physicochemical characteristics of the river. The temperatures of the river (Triver), the turbidity (Turb), the total dissolved solids (STD) and the electrical conductivity (CE), were measured during each collection of ichthyoplankton. The Triver was measured with a mercury thermometer with a precision of ±0.5°C (BRIXCO, United Kingdom). Turb was measured with a portable digital turbidimeter (Orbeco-Hellige, the USA); whereas CE and STD were measured using a digital conductimeter (WTW, LF538, the USA). An average value per day for each one of these parameters was estimated from the three daily readings.
Characterization of rainfall (Pluv), solar brightness (Bs) and cloudiness (Nub). The daily records of Pluv, Bs and Nub, were obtained from the URRA I Weather Center Station, located at the dam (Tierralta, Córdoba).
Statistical analysis. No environmental variable studied (Qriver, ΔQriver, Vriver, Triver, Turb, EC, STD, Pluv, Bs and Nub) or Dl met the assumptions of normality (Shapiro-Wilk test) and homogeneity (Levene test). A descriptive statistic (average±standard deviation) of all environmental variables considered during every day of the study (184 days) and the days in which spawning presence (ichthyoplankton) was detected, was carried out. During the studied period, Dl of the different species was compared though a non-parametric ANOVA (Kruskal-Wallis test) and when differences were observed, Dunnett’s multiple comparison per pairs test was used (p<0.05). To determine the association between the studied environmental variables and the reproduction of the fish (presence of ichthyoplankton), a correlation analysis (Spearman Coefficient) and a Main Component Analysis (ACP) was conducted. The data was transformed through Log (Xi+1) before their analysis. The statistical analysis was conducted with using of the Statgraphic Centurion (6) and XLSTAT (vs. 2011) programs.
RESULTS
Identification of ichthyoplankton by species. During the study period, 8284 embryos were captured, of which the most common reophilic species found were bocachico (36.3%), dorada (0.5%), bagre blanco (1.6%) and barbul (0.6%). Embryos of bocachico, barbul, bagre blanco and other species were captured predominantly in blastomeration stage; whereas the dorada was collected, mainly, in pharyngulation stage (Table 1). This group of species represented 61.1% of the total ichthyoplankton captured.
Reproductive frequency and larval density. In 30.4% of the days of the evaluated period (184 days), a presence of ichthyoplankton was observed; April and May were the months with more Fr. June and July showed a reduction in FR; while a slight increase of Fr was observed in August (22.6%), September (26.7%) and October(53.3%) (Table 2). In 30.4% of the total studied days, a presence of spawning of the other group of species was observed, followed by the bocachico (21.7%); while bagre blanco (5.4%), dorada (3.8%) and barbul (1.6%) registered a decrease in Fr.
The highest Dlm was registered in April (19.8 larvae/m3), which diminished with the passing of the months, reaching minimum values at the end of the reproductive season (September and October with 0.7±0.3 and 1.2±0.3 larvae/m3, respectively). The highest Dlm per species was registered for the group of other species (2.9±1.7 larvae/m3) and bocachico (1.8±1.7 larvae/m3). Ichthyoplankton from the other group of species was registered during the whole reproductive period; in September, no spawning of bocachico was registered. Dorada was observed during the first two months and during the fourth month of the study; while the bagre blanco was observed during the first four months of the study. Barbul was only registered in May (Table 3).
Environmental characteristic of the reproductive season of migratory fish. The daily Qriver during the study’s period presented values that ranged between 278.7 and 838.5 m3/s, with averages of 651.0 m3/s. But when fish spawning appeared, the maximum values were 792.7 m3/s for the bocachico, dorada, bagre blanco and barbul species; and minimums values of 543.1 3 m3/s for the group other species (Figure 1).
ΔQriver during the period ranged between 0.0 and 100.7 m3/s. When spawning of species like bocachico and bagre blanco appeared, the values ranged between 1.0 and 88.3 m3/s; while the dorada spawning occurred with values that ranged between 1.0 and 92.1 m3/s. Barbul spawning appeared with values that ranged between 1.0 and 100.7 m3/s (Figure 1).
Vriver during the period showed values that ranged between 1.40 and 1.53 m/s and fish spawning appeared during this period (Figure 1).
Pluv during the period of the study showed values that ranged between 0.0 and 1.53 and 88.2 mm; during this same interval, migratory fish spawning appeared.
Triver during the reproductive season showed values that ranged between 26.7 and 29.0°C; while spawning appeared in the interval between 27.0 and 28.7°C (Figure 1).
STD values during the period ranged between 73.0 and 302.3 mg/L; dorada, bagre blanco and bocachico spawning appeared in this interval; while barbul spawning appeared in the interval between 99.3 and 119.0 mg/L (Figure 1).
Turb during the reproductive period ranged between 9.7 and 679.7 NTU (mean=139.1 NTU); bocachico, dorada (22.6-679.7 NTU) and bagre blanco (53.5-679.7 NTU) spawned in similar intervals; while barbul spawning appeared in the interval between 112.1 and 659.3 NTU (Figure 1).
CE during the reproductive period showed values that ranged between 81.0 and 361.7 µS/cm. Bocachico, dorada and bagre blanco spawning appeared in a similar interval (81.0-325.7 µS/cm); while barbul spawning appeared in an interval between 99.7-128.5 µS/cm (Figure 1).
Bs values during the reproductive period ranged between 0.0 and 11.2 hours. The values were similar to those values of the period where the bocachico, dorada, bagre blanco and other species were recorded. Barbul spawning occurred with minimum values of 1.6 and maximum values of 7.5 hours (Figure 1).
Nub values during the period ranged between 2.0 and 7.3 octave; bochachico and barbul spawning appeared (2.0-7.0 octave) and dorada and bagre blanco (2.0-6.3 octave) in similar intervals (Figure 1).
Correlation between environmental variables and migratory fish spawning. Qriver, Vriver, Triver and Pluv, were the variables that showed the highest number of significant relations. Bocachico spawning is related to Qriver, Vriver and Triver, as well as STD and Pluv (p<0.05). Bagre blanco spawning, as well as bocachico spawning, were directly correlated to Qriver, Vriver and Triver, and inversely correlated to Bs. Dorada and barbul spawning were associated with Pluv and Nub, respectively. The other species group had a similar behavior to the bocachico species correlating with Qriver, Vriver, Triver and Pluv (Table 4).
Analysis of Main Components. In figure 2, the formation of two big groups can be observed: the first group is composed by the environmental variables Qriver, Vriver, Triver, STD, Nub and Pluv, that showed a high relation with spawning of all type of reophilic species of the Sinu river; while the second group was composed by the environmental variables ΔQriver, CE, Turb and BS, which are not related with the main species of reophilic spawning in this river.
DISCUSSION
The collection of ichthyoplankton was composed, mainly, by migratory fish embryos of the Characiformes order (Prochilodus magdalenae and Brycon sinuensis) and the Siluriformes order (Sorubim cuspicaudus and Pimelodus blochii). According to Maldonado-Ocampo et al (7) of the 1435 fish species that live in Colombia’s fresh water systems, the orders that make up the most species of the continent’s ichthyofauna are Characiformes, with 637 species (44%) and Siluriformes, with 524 species (37%). Jimenez-Segura et al (4), also reported that 64% of the ichthyoplankton of the Magdalena river belong to the migratory fish group of the Characiformes order (P. magdalenae, Leporinus muyscorum, Curimata mivartii, Salminus affinis and Brycon sp.) and Siluriformes (Pimelodus spp., Pseudoplatystoma magdaleniatum, S. cuspicaudus). Also, in other South American rivers, such as the Uruguay river, it was found that the largest abundance of larva collected belongs to the Characiformes order (3).
When analyzing the results by species, it was observed that the highest Dl in the Sinu river was shown by Prochilodus magdalenae, which is the most important species of the Colombian continental fisheries and the Prochilodus genus, which is the most abundant in species in the South American continental waters (7). Pimelodids S. cuspicaudus and P. blochii, showed the lowest larval abundance during the studies reproductive season.
Fr during the study’s period indicated that the presence of ichthyoplankton was observed (reproductive activity) in only in 30.4% of the days . The months of April and May were the months with the most reproductive activity while in terms of frequency, like the Dl (which suggests that despite spawning appearing during the studied period (April-October), the first two months (April-May) are the months of highest reproductive activity and of highest larval density when compared to the rest of the period. These results suggest that in the Sinu river basin the highest reproductive activity of migratory fish occurs at the beginning of the rainy season, stimulated by the variations of abiotic factors caused by the start of the first rainy period of the year.
The Dl average of the estimated ichthyoplankton in Carrizola (Tierralta) as an indicator of the abundance of larval was 4.9 larvae/m3, which is higher than the records reported in the Magdalena river (2.5 larvae/m3) (4). It’s possible that the difference between these numbers is due to the sampling structure; in this study, an estimated average for the entire reproductive season is presented (184 days), considering only the days with spawning presence; while in the Magdalena rive, the amount of days evaluated was 72 days in two years of study. Salete-Daga et al (8) reported larval densities of 2.9 individuals/m3 in to floodable plains with different degrees of connection with the Parana river, Brazil; while Reynalte-Tatage et al (9) reported densities of 0.1 larvae/m3 in the Ivinhema river, Brazil.
The Sinu river, despite being a river intervened by the construction of the HU, presented a strong variation in the values of the parameters that describe water mass caused by rainfall season, which is characterized by cyclical and temporary disorders during the transition between shallow and high waters and vice versa. The alterations caused by the increase in water levels are characterized by the increase in the river’s flow, velocity, electric conductivity, turbidity and total dissolved solids and by the reduction of temperature. Similar conditions were reported for the Magdalena river with the difference that this river showed stronger daily fluctuations(4).
In this study, it was observed that spawning appeared when the river flows were above 790 ms3/s; agreeing with Baumgartner et al’s proposal (2), who considered that this condition was the only way for these species’ larva to reach floodable plains that are not connected to the rivers during dry season. Both in the upper part of the Parana river as well as in the floodable plains, a higher Dl of Pimelodus, Auchenipterus osteomystax and Iheringichthys labrosus was reported when the water level was high (2,10).
In the Sinu river, the results suggest that the variables associated to the spawning of reophilic fish were the river’s flow, velocity, temperature, rainfall, total dissolved solids, cloudiness and solar brilliance. Jiménez-Safe et al (4) suggest that in the Magdalena river during both annual hydrologic cycles (2004-2005), Dl increased when a reduction in solar brilliant, an increase in cloudiness, an increase in rainfall and a fluctuation of synchronized water appeared with specific moments of low lunar brightness (4). In the upper part of the Uruguay river (Brazil), the abundance of eggs and larva showed a strong seasonal variation related to the higher flow values and water temperature as well as lower dissolved oxygen values, pH and transparency (3).
In the Sinu river, spawning of P. magdalenae, S. cuspicaudus and other species are related to more than three parameters, being the river’s flow, velocity, temperature, and rainfall common factors in these species; while B. sinuensis and P. blochii were only correlated to rainfall and cloudiness, respectively. In the Magdalena river, Dl of S. cuspicaudus, Pimelodus spp. and P. magdalenae was increased before the start of the currents when some reduction in solar brilliance was evident and the stability index began to decrease due to changes in the increase of rainfall and total dissolved solids (4).
In the high plains of the Portuguesa river (Venezuela), the presence of eggs between three and five times per year was recorded only when an increase in the river’s level was observed with water speeds between 0.59 to 1.06 m/s and generally, after the maximum flood level (11). In the upper Uruguay river (Brazil), eggs and yolk-sac larvae in the river rapids and mouth, with average speeds between 0.84 and 0.50 m/s were observed (3). In the Sinu river, these events were observed with average speeds above 1.41 m/s.
In the Sinu river, the electric conductivity was not related to spawning of migratory fish, but they were related to the temperature. In the Cuiba, Mato Gross river (Brazil), the higher densities of embryos and larvae are related to the places with low concentrations of dissolved oxygen, electric conductivity and transparency, larger width of the river and intermediate depths (12). In the flood plain of the upper Parana river, the electric conductivity was positively correlated with the ichthyoplankton density (8); likewise, a positive linear ratio was observed between the abundance of total larvae and the environmental conditions; which suggests that the higher abundance of larvae was related to higher values of electric conductivity and temperature (near 30°C) (8).
In this study, the highest spawning of reophilic fish in the Sinu river appeared between April and May, when the temperature showed values between 27.0 and 28.7°C. The highest reproductive intensity of many species of the Upper Parana river occurs between October and January (13), when the water temperatures are higher. Bialetzki et al (10) found strong relations between the ichthyoplankton community and the environmental variables in the Bahia river, mainly related with the temperature, the dissolved oxygen, the rainfall and the velocity. According to Jimenez-Segura (4) the photoperiod and the temperature are related to physicochemical processes associated with rainfall, such as the reduction in the intensity of solar brilliance, the increase in clouds and the increase in the water level, causing the reduction of the temperature.
In the Sinu river, the total dissolved solids were only correlated with P. magdalenae dissolves. In the Magdalena rive, the migratory fish spawning were related to total dissolved solids and the turbulence that characterizes the river currents period (4).
In the Sinu river, solar brilliance was only correlated inversely to S. cuspicaudus, spawning; whereas, in the river Magdalena, the change in maximum number of hours of solar brilliance between the months with higher and lower precipitation (about 2 hours), defined by temporary cloudiness patters, seem to define the chronology in the reproduction of reophilic fish (4).
The results of this work allow to conclude that the highest reproductive activity, in terms of Fr and Dl, was at the beginning of the rainy season (April and May). The abiotic parameters of the river’s flow, temperature, velocity, rainfall, total dissolved solids and cloudiness can be considered as final factors that stimulate the reproduction of reophilic fish. The spawning of P. magdalenae and S. cuspicaudus were stimulated by the river’s flow, velocity and temperature; while the rainfall and the total dissolved solids stimulated the spawning of P. magdalenae. The spawning of B. sinuensis was stimulated only by rainfall; while the spawning of P. blochii was stimulated only by cloudiness.
Acknowledgments
To the Urra SA-ESP Hydroelectric for financing this study.
REFERENCES
1. Avendaño-Ibarra R, Funes-Rodríguez R, Hinojosa-Medina A, González-Armas R, Aceves-Medina G. Seasonal abundance of fish larvae in a subtropical lagoon in the west coast of the Baja California Peninsula. Estuar Coast Shelf Sci 2004; 61(1):125-135.
2. Baumgartner G, Nakatani K, Gomes LC, Bialetzki A, Sanches PV, Makrakis MC. Fish larvae from the upper Paraná River: do abiotic factors affect larval density? Neotrop Ichthyol 2008; 6(4):551-558.
3. Alves Da Silva P, Reynalte-Tataje DA, Zaniboni-Filho E. Identification of fish nursery areas in a free tributary of an impoundment region, upper Uruguay River, Brazil. Neotrop Ichthyol 2012; 10(2):425-438.
4. Jiménez-Segura LF, Palacio J, Leite R. River flooding and reproduction of migratory fish species in the Magdalena River basin, Colombia. Ecol Freshw Fish 2010; 19(2):178–186.
5. Arias-Gallo M, Jiménez-Segura LF, Dorado M Del P. Desarrollo larval de Prochilodus magdalenae (Steindachner, 1879) (Pisces: Prochilodontidae), río Magdalena, Colombia. Actual Biol 2010; 32(93):199-208.
6. Statistical Graphics Corp. Statgraphics Centurion 5.0. 2011.
7. Maldonado-Ocampo J, Vari R, Usma J. Checklist of the freshwater fishes of Colombia. Biota Colombiana 2008; 9(2):143–237.
8. Salete-Daga V, Gogola M, Vanderlei-Sanches P, Baumgartner G, Baumgartner D, Augusto Piana P, André Gubiani E, Luciana Delariva R. Fish larvae assemblages in two floodplain lakes with different degrees of connection to the Paraná River, Brazil. Neotrop Ichthyol 2009; 7(3):429-438.
9. Reynalte-Tataje DA, Nakatani K, Fernandes R, Agostinho AA, Bialetzki A. Temporal distribution of ichthyoplankton in the Ivinhema River (Mato Grosso do Sul State/ Brazil): Influence of environmental variables. Neotrop Ichthyol 2011; 9(2):427-436.
10. Bialetzki A, Nakatani K, Sanches PV, Baumgartner G, Gomes LC. Larval fish assemblage in the Bahia River (Mato Grosso do Sul State, Brazil): temporal and spatial patters. Environ Biol Fishes 2005; 73(1):37-47.
11. Rodríguez-Olarte D, Kossowski C. Reproducción de peces y consideración de ambientes en eventos de crecidas en el río Portuguesa, Venezuela. Rev Bioagro 2004; 16(2):143-147.
12. Ramalho Ziober S, Bialetzki A, Aparecida De Fátima Mateus L. Effect of abiotic variables on fish eggs and larvae distribution in headwaters of Cuiabá River, Mato Grosso State, Brazil. Neotrop Ichthyol 2012; 10(1):123-132.
13. Gogola T, Daga V, Da Silva P, Sanches P, Gubiani É, Baumgartner G, Delariva R. Spatial and temporal distribution patterns of ichthyoplankton in a region affected by water regulation by dams. Neotrop Ichthyol 2010; 8(2):341-349.
